Title: [Evidence based indications for tonsillectomy].
Author: Wolfensberger M, Mund MT.
Journal: Ther Umsch; 2004 May; 61(5):325-8. PubMed ID: 15195718.
Abstract:
Tonsillectomy (TE) is one of the most frequent as well as one of the most controversial surgical interventions. The objective of this paper was to assess the evidence of the most common indications for TE. For this purpose the literature of the past 25 years was analysed using the criteria of evidence based medicine. In children seventy-five percent of TEs are performed because of recurrent tonsillitis. Several randomised clinical trials (RCTs) have demonstrated the efficacy of TE in this disease. This indication is based on evidence grade I-II. No consensus has yet been reached, however, about the number of annual episodes that justify TE. The remaining paediatric TEs are performed to relieve symptoms of airway obstruction. TE has been shown to improve obstructive symptoms in up to 100% of patients. It is the accepted treatment of paediatric obstructive sleep apnoea, although the evidence is not based on major RCTs. In adults, too, the majority of TEs are performed for recurrent or chronic tonsillitis. There are no good RCTs, but the indication can be based on a series of well controlled studies (evidence grade III). Obviously, TE is indicated if there is suspicion of neoplasm. Peritonsillar abscess per se is no indication for TE, unless the abscess cannot be drained otherwise. TE plays no role in the standard management of OSAS and mononucleosis.
